the carroll group

Crime Writing  
Short Stories

HomeFiction Writing Tips • 2009-02-04 Why Ross is out of favour

Home

Blog on Writing

Elgin Last Week

Preview or Order Books by Terry Carroll

Reviews of Snow Candy

Upcoming Readings and Signings

Links

Short Stories

Volunteer and Work Experience

Contact Us

Terry's blog on Writing



Why Ross is out of favour
Posted February 4, 2009

I've had the mixed blessing of reading a late Ross MacDonald mystery THE GOODBYE LOOK.

It has all the trademark touches . . . a plot so complicated there should be a chart, beautiful metaphors interspersed with descriptive writing that's occasionally a stretch, plot lines and relationships that go back and back and back.

While Ross MacDonald has recently been reprinted, for a time, his books were out of print, whereas most of John D. MacDonald's have remained in print.

Sure John D. is a lighter writer, and Travis McGee is a character closer to the sensibilities of the 21st century than Ross's Lew Archer.

But I think Ross's writing has also suffered because of the ongoing shift in how we view psychiatry.

There seems to be much of Freud in John D, a little too much for our time.

Site last updated on April 24, 2018, at 07:55 AM

© 2018, The Carroll Group • Website Design by InternetAdvisor.caSite Map